Nov 01, 2021 Natural Resources Committee

[1. CALL TO ORDER ]

[00:00:10]

MEETING OF THE NATURAL RESOURCE COMMITTEE. >> AND CALL IT TO ORDER AND WE

WILL STAND FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> KEITH I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO MY OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD. INDIVISIBLE FOR LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.

THANK YOU. HAS PUBLIC NOTICE OF THIS MEETING BEEN PUBLISHED POSTED

[4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA ]

OF THE AGENDA. >> SO MOVEMENT AND CHAIRMAN MOTION MADE BY COUNCILMAN

GLOVER IS OUR SECOND HERE. SECOND I'LL SECOND THE MOTION. >> THANK YOU.

[5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - SEPTEMBER 7, 2021 ]

COUNTS FROM GLOVER MADE A MOTION. >> I NEED A SECOND TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 7. TWO THOUSAND TWENTY ONE A MOVE .

>> BECAUSE I CAN. OK. >> THAT WAS DONE BY COUNCILMAN

[6. CITIZEN COMMENTS ]

DO WE HAVE ANYONE IN THE AUDIENCE THAT WOULD LIKE TO MAKE CITIZENS COMMENTS OR ONLINE? YES MA'AM. IT FEELS.

STATE YOUR NAME. COME FORWARD FOR THE RECORD. >> MY NAME IS MARY MALLOY AND I'M. I'M HERE. I DON'T KNOW IF I WOULD GET THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK HERE AT NUMBER 9. I'M HERE IN THE EVENT THAT YOU

HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE NUMBER 9 ON THE HAND. >> OK.

>> YOU CAN. I DON'T WANT TO GET AHEAD. I GUESS I DIDN'T KNOW IF YOU YEAH. WELL IF YOU'D LIKE TO MAKE SOME COMMENTS NOW THAT WOULD BE

FINE. >> ABOUT NUMBER 9 OK. NUMBER 9 THAT'S THE PROPERTY AT MY PARENTS JUST SIMILAR VENUE MY LADIES I'LL EM FOR US AND MY SIBLINGS BE ALL HAVE HOME AND MY PARENTS WERE ENTERTAINERS AND THEY TOOK CARE OF THE COMMUNITY THEY HELPED IN THE COMMUNITY AND WE THOUGHT IT WOULD ONLY BE FITTING BECAUSE THEY ALWAYS HAD PEOPLE IN AND

OUT OF THEIR HOME. >> YOU KNOW WE WANT TO DO SOMETHING IN MEMORY OF OUR PARENTS SO WE WANT TO DO A SHORT TERM AIR BEING BEAT. WE DID NOT SHORT TERM RENTAL.

WE DID NOT WANT TO HAVE SOMEONE JUST LIVING IN THERE. WE WANT TO BE HAVE SOME INPUT BECAUSE WE WANT TO USE THE HOME. IN BETWEEN THAT IS NOT FEASIBLE TO DO THAT. THERE'S SOMEONE IN THERE ALL THE TIME.

I LIVE RIGHT BEHIND THE PROPERTY SO WE'LL BE ABLE TO OVERSEE AND SEE HOW THINGS WORK WITH THAT. BUT THAT'S WHY I'M HERE. WE WANT TO DO SOMETHING WITH OUR PARENTS. PROPERTY HAS BEEN SITTING FOR A WHILE AND BECAUSE OF ALL THE PROBLEMS THAT WE HAVE ENCOUNTERED, YOU KNOW WE NOW KNOW WHAT TO DO AND WE ARE DOING IT. AND SO I'M HERE IN THE EVENT THAT YOU MAY HAVE QUESTIONS.

THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYONE ONLINE WITH

PUBLIC COMMENTS AT THIS TIME? >> YES, THERE IS. SHE'S JUST UNNEEDED.

OK. IF YOU FEEL STATE YOU CAN FOR THE RECORD.

YES. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS MARY RYAN KRIEGER.

GOOD AFTERNOON AND THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK. MY NAME IS MARIANNE KRIEGER AND I'M THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR GOVERNMENT AND EXTERNAL RELATIONS AT MARINE CORPS AIR STATION BEAUFORT. THANK YOU AGAIN FOR YOUR TIME AND YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK REGARDING. AGENDA ITEM 10 THE PROPOSED ZONING MAP AMENDMENT AND REZONING REQUEST FOR 27 06 TRESTLE PARKWAY. THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN THE ACCIDENT POTENTIAL ZONE 2 WHICH IS ALSO NOISE ZONE 3 WORD NOISE LEVELS CAN REACH UP TO 80 TO 85 DECIBELS. THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE AIR INSTALLATIONS COMPATIBLE USE SOME STUDY OR THE ACRES STUDY IDENTIFIES THESE SOUNDS AS WHERE AN AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT IS MOST LIKELY TO OCCUR IN THE VICINITY OF THE AIRFIELD AND DUE TO THIS PROPERTY BEING LOCATED IN THE ACCIDENT CENTRAL ZONE TO RAND CORPS AIR STATION IT WILL CONTINUE TO PROPOSE TO OPPOSE THIS REZONING REQUEST DUE TO ITS STRONG INCOMPATIBILITY WITH THE CREWS AND ESPECIALLY ON THE BASIS OF PUBLIC SAFETY. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU. ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENTS? >> YES.

[00:05:01]

TO SECTION CAUSE A HORRIBLE WELL WHAT NORMALLY. >> WHAT WE DO IS WE HAVE A PUBLIC COMMENT AT THE BEGINNING OF THE MEETING SO IT'S WOULD WE PREFER YOU GO AHEAD AND MAKE

YOUR PUBLIC COMMENT NOW. OK. >> YOU'RE RECOMMENDATIONS, WAYNE SMITH. YES. HI.

I'M DEFINITELY HERE IN SUPPORT OF NUMBER 9 AND I DON'T KNOW NOT ONLY ALONG WITH MY SUPPORT OF IT BUT ADJACENT PROPERTIES TO TO THAT THEY ARE IN COMMERCIAL COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES. SO I DON'T BELIEVE WHAT THEY'RE ASKING FOR IS NOT WITH WHAT IS CURRENTLY EXISTING ADJACENT TO THAT. SO I THINK AND THE QUESTION ALSO COMES ABOUT HOW MANY PEOPLE ARE DOING AND BEING BEES ARE REALLY THERE HAVE NOT ARRESTED. SO I SO I REALLY MY HEART GOES OFF THEM FOR BEING RESPECTABLE TO THE COUNTY AND ACTUALLY GOING ABOUT THE CORRECT WAY. SO I THINK THAT I BELIEVE THAT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE DOING IN THE KIND TAXES ARE GOING UP AND KIND OF ASKING PEOPLE FOR MONEY. SO I DON'T THINK THAT THE COUNTY SHOULD TACTFULLY DENY ANYONE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE TO PAY THEIR TAXES TO PAY BILLS AND IF THAT'S WHAT THE FAMILY IS ASKING FOR THAT I THINK THAT THE COUNTY COUNCIL ORDER GO AHEAD AND MOVE FORWARD AND GRANT AND GRANT THEM THAT BECAUSE THEY TRIED TO WITH THE CORRECT WAY AND DID TRIED TO RESPECT THE BOY DOING THAT. AND SO AT THE I I'M HEARING SUPPORT OF THAT AND I BELIEVE THAT WE OUGHT TO GIVE THEM THE FULL TIME TO DO THEIR PROPERTY WHAT THEY RIGHTFULLY DESERVE TO

[7. AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT UTILITY ORDINANCE AS ADOPTED SEPTEMBER 26, 2016 TO PROVIDE FOR THE ADOPTION OF STORMWATER MANAGEMENT STANDARDS SET FORTH IN THE SOUTHERN LOWCOUNTRY DESIGN MANUAL TO MEET THE MUNICIPAL SEPARATE STORMSEWER SYSTEM (MS4) PERMIT REQUIREMENTS ]

DO WITH IT. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU.

OK, ANY OTHER COMMENTS? >> NONE. OK.

WELL, MOVING ON TO NUMBER 7 IS AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT UTILITY ORDINANCE AS ADOPTED SEPTEMBER 26, 2006 SAYING TO PROVIDE FOR THE ADOPTION OF STORMWATER MANAGEMENT STANDARDS SET FORTH IN THE SOUTHERN LOW COUNTRY DESIGN MANUAL BETTER KNOWN AS LOW SO LOCAL MANUAL TO MEET THE MUNICIPAL SEPARATE STORMWATER SYSTEM M.S. FOR PERMIT REQUIREMENTS AND ONLINE. I THINK WE HAVE MR. FRYE ALEX. MR. DECIDES THAT CORRECT?

ARE THEY THE ONES TO SPEAK TO THIS? >> THIS IS JERRY NEAL.

ARE YOU THERE? >> I CAN DO IT. OK.

SO LEAVE ARE CHANGES AS YOU'RE AWARE WE'VE MADE SOME UPDATES ARE THE SLOWER THE MANUAL DESIGN MANUAL WAS PASSED ON AUTUMN MANUALS PASSED LAST YEAR AND ADOPTED BY THE MUNICIPALITIES. THESE ARE SOME SMALL AND MINOR UPDATES JUST FROM IMPLEMENTATION AND PRACTICE THAT WE THOUGHT WAS BEST JUST TO CODIFY THAT BACK IN THE MANUAL AND IN DOING SO OBVIOUSLY IT WAS PASSED ORDINANCE AND MODIFIED WITH MEDIA DEVELOPMENT. THAT SPLIT. THESE ARE IN REFERENCE TO WELL OF ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNCIL MEMBERS. I HAVE JUST ONE COMMENT.

THE STORMWATER BOARD HAS REVIEWED THIS CORRECT? I THINK THEY DID A COUPLE

MEETINGS OR THAT THEY HAD. YES, MA'AM. >> OKAY.

AND WE HAVE ANOTHER COUNCIL MEMBER WHO HAS JOINED COUNCILMAN DAWSON.

IS ANYONE ON ONLINE HAVE ANY COMMENTS? I WOULD LIKE TO ENTERTAIN A MOTION IF THERE'S NO MORE COMMENTS TO APPROVE THE ADOPTION OF THE PROPOSAL.

SO LOCO DESIGN MANUAL UPDATE I'LL MAKE THE MOTION YEMEN OK. >> I HEARD COUNCILMAN PARSIMONY MAKE THE MOTION. COUNCILMAN DAWSON, DON'T HEAR A SECOND FROM YOU.

I'LL SECOND IT. THANK YOU. WITHOUT OBJECTION THIS MOTION WILL PASS TO ADOPT THE PROPOSED SOUTHERN LOW COUNTRY DESIGN MANUAL UPDATES.

[8. AN ORDINANCE FOR A TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT UTILITY ORDINANCE AS ADOPTED SEPTEMBER 26TH, 2016 TO ADDRESS THE ADOPTION OF THE SOUTHERN LOWCOUNTRY DESIGN MANUAL ]

>> AND NEXT IT WILL GO TO COUNTY COUNCIL FOR FIRST READING.

ALL RIGHT. ITEM NUMBER EIGHT IS AN ORDINANCE FOR TAX AMENDMENT TO THE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT UTILITY ORDINANCE AS ADOPTED SEPTEMBER 26, 2016 TO ADDRESS THE ADOPTION OF THE SOUTHERN LOW COUNTRY DESIGN MANUAL. WE'RE GOING TO TAKE THAT ONE.

IT'S A MATTER. >> SO AGAIN, JUST AN OVERALL MATTER OF DATES AND THEN BECAUSE OF UPDATING THE MANUAL TO GET IT IN THE ORDINANCE SAY WILL THE MUNICIPALITIES BE ADOPTING THESE TWO SET PLAN TEN YEARS THE WILL COORDINATE WITH THEM.

>> I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'LL HAVE THAT UPDATED EVERY TIME WE MAKE AN UPDATE BUT WE'LL DEFINITELY COORDINATE WITH THEM AS THAT. ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS FROM COUNTY COUNCIL MEMBERS PRESENT?

[00:10:01]

CODE OF ORDINANCES. >> I'LL MAKE THE MOTION. THANK YOU.

CAN SWIM PAST ME. I HAVE A SECOND CITY COUNCILMAN GLOVER.

>> MAY THE SECOND RIGHT. >> WITHOUT EXCEPTION WE'LL BE APPROVED AND WE'LL MOVE ON TO

[9. AN ORDINANCE FOR A TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE (CDC): SECTION A.3.40 (PERMITTED ACTIVITIES) TO REVISE THE LADY’S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT TO INCLUDE SHORT-TERM RENTALS AS A SPECIAL USE. ]

NUMBER NINE IS THE ONE WE HAD A COUPLE OF PUBLIC COMMENTS ABOUT .

THIS IS AN ORDINANCE FOR A TAX AMENDMENT TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE CDC SECTION A POINT THREE POINT FOUR ZERO PERMITTED ACTIVITIES TO REVIVE THE LADY'S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT TO INCLUDE SHORT TERM RENTALS AS A SPECIAL USE.

GOOD AFTERNOON. GOOD AFTERNOON. CHAIRWOMAN AND COMMITTEE

MEMBERS. >> SO THIS IS AN APPLICATION TO ADD A SHORT TERM RENTALS TO THE

LADY'S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT. >> THIS IS A COMMUNITY PRESERVATION DISTRICT AND WAR CHEMICALS ARE CURRENTLY NOT ALLOWED IN SEPTEMBER OF LAST

YEAR. >> SHORT TERM RENTALS WERE ADOPTED INTO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR ALL OF OUR TRANSACT ZONES EXCEPT 41 NATURAL PRESERVE AND OUR

CONVENTIONAL ZONES AS A SPECIAL USE. >> AND IN IT WAS NOT INCLUDED IN INDUSTRIAL OR IN OUR COMMUNITY PRESERVATION DISTRICTS.

>> AND SO THAT'S THE REASON THIS IS BEFORE YOU ALL TODAY. SHORT TERM RENTALS ARE NOT

CURRENTLY IN OUR COMMUNITY PRESERVATION DISTRICTS. >> THE LADY'S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT IS A DISTRICT THAT IS INTENDED TO ALLOW SMALL SCALE RETAIL AND BUSINESS SMALL CIVIC USES, COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND RESIDENTIAL.

>> SO IT'S A MIXED USE DISTRICT . >> THE CORRIDOR THAT IT CONTAINS IS SAM'S POINT ROAD CORRIDOR FROM MOORE DRIVE ALL THE WAY UP TO THE ROUNDABOUT SO IT FLANKS EITHER SIDE OF THAT LARGELY COMMERCIAL CONDITIONS CURRENTLY ON THAT PORTION

OF THE CORRIDOR. >> THERE ARE A COUPLE OF PLANT UNIT DEVELOPMENTS SO A COUPLE OF NEIGHBORHOODS INCLUDED IN THAT PORTION BUT OTHERWISE RELATIVELY COMMERCIAL.

>> THE APPLICANT IS THE OWNER OF 160 SAM'S POINT ROAD WHICH AS YOU HEARD IS CURRENTLY A RESIDENTIAL USE AND SO IT WOULD BE APPLICABLE IT WOULD ALIGN WITH SHORT TERM RENTALS AS AS

CURRENT USE. >> SO WITH THE LEASE ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE TRANSACT ZONES THAT CURRENTLY ALLOW OUR SHORT TERM UNTIL USES.

>> AND SO IN ASSESSING THIS WE LOOKED AT THE CURRENT USES ALONG THE CORRIDOR THAT THAT MAKE UP THE LADY'S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT .

>> THE INTENT OF THE DISTRICT WHAT OTHER TRANSACT ZONES ALLOW IT AND HOW THEY COMPARE THE USE ON THE PROPERTY AND ESSENTIALLY DETERMINE THAT THIS IS AN APPROPRIATE ADDITION TO THE LADY'S ISLAND EXPANDED HOME BUSINESS DISTRICT. IT WOULD BE A SPECIAL USE IF APPROVED SO IT WOULD HAVE TO GO BEFORE THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS AFTER STAFF GOES THROUGH THAT PROCESS AT SRT AND AND THAT IS WHERE IT SITS SHOULD OPEN IT UP FOR ANY

QUESTIONS. >> CHAIRMAN I'M GOING TO HAVE TO RECUSE MYSELF.

>> I OWN RENTAL PROPERTY ON THAT CORRIDOR. >> OKAY.

AND I WOULD LIKE TO INCLUDE THAT THE BECAUSE IT'S COMMUNITY PRESERVATION DISTRICT.

>> WE DID TAKE THIS TO THE LADY'S ISLAND COMMUNITY PRESERVATION COMMITTEE AND THEY REVIEWED IT DURING THEIR SEPTEMBER MEETING AND WE'RE NOT OPPOSED TO THE ADDITION

OF SHORT TERM RENTAL TO THIS DISTRICT. >> IT ALSO WENT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION DURING THEIR OCTOBER MEETING WHERE IT WAS UNANIMOUSLY RECOMMENDED FOR

APPROVAL OR ANY QUESTIONS ANYONE ONLINE. >> SO JUST JUST TO CLARIFY THIS WILL ALLOW FOR THIS PARTICULAR PIECE OF PROPERTY TO GO TO THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS TO

ALLOW SHORT TERM RENTAL CAR. YES. >> AND IT WOULD ALLOW IT IN THE ENTIRE DISTRICT ARE JUST IF ANYONE LIVING HAS PROPERTY IN THAT DISTRICT THEY COULD APPLY

FOR A SHORT MENTAL APPLICATION. >> OK, VERY GOOD. THE NEW AGENCY HAS OUTLINED THE

MAP THAT YOU HAVE. YES. >> AND IT'S I DON'T KNOW IF YOU HAVE AN IMAGE WE CAN PULL IT UP. IT'S INCLUDED IN THE PACKET SORT OF GO FROM ALL LEGAL ROAD TO SHORT LANDING I GUESS. YEAH.

I BELIEVE MILLER DRIVE ALL THE WAY UP TO THAT ROUNDABOUT AREA HERE.

>> THAT'S WHAT WE HOPE AND IT FLANKS EITHER SIDE. SECOND, OK, I THINK COUNCILMAN DAWSON, DID YOU HAVE A QUESTION ? YES, I WAS GOING TO MAKE A MOTION, MADAM CHAIRMAN, IF YOU'RE READY TO ENTERTAIN. I THINK WE ARE.

>> YES, SIR. I MOVED. WE APPROVED OF OUR FOURTH AMENDMENT TO THE COUNTY DEVELOPMENT CODE SECTION A A THREE FORTY TO REVISE THE MEDIA EXAM AND EXPANDED ON BUSINESS DISTRICT TO INCLUDE SHORT TERM RENTALS THAT HAVE A SECOND.

>> SECOND. THANK YOU. SECOND BY COUNCILMAN GLOVER.

ALL RIGHT. ANY DISCUSSION WITHOUT EXCEPTION THIS WILL BE FORD

[00:15:05]

[10. AN ORDINANCE FOR A ZONING MAP AMENDMENT/REZONING REQUEST FOR 2 ACRES (R100 020 000 0020 0000) AT 2706 TRASK PARKWAY FROM T2 RURAL NEIGHBORHOOD TO C4 COMMUNITY CENTER MIXED USE ]

>> NUMBER 10 YOU'LL BE PRESENTING THAT ONE TOO. THANK YOU.

YES. THAT IS AN ORDINANCE FOR A ZONING MAP AMENDMENT SLASH REZONING REQUEST FOR TWO ACRES AT TWENTY SEVEN O SIX TRASK PARKWAY FROM T TO WORLD NEIGHBORHOOD TO SEE FOR COMMUNITY CENTER MIXED USE. YES.

>> YES. SO THIS IS AS YOU'VE JUST MENTIONED TWO ACRES AT TWENTY SEVEN O SIX TRASK PARKWAY. I DO HAVE A POWERPOINT PRESENTATION JUST TO SHOW YOU SOME IMAGES OF THE PROPERTY WHAT IT CURRENTLY LOOKS LIKE BUT A LITTLE BACKGROUND.

>> THIS PROPERTY HAS BEEN FOR MANY DECADES PRIOR TO 2018 A GAS STATION.

IT WAS PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS THE DOBBS STORE. SO SOME OF YOU MAY BE FAMILIAR WITH IT. IT'S BEEN AN EXISTING BUILDING AND BUSINESS FOR QUITE SOME TIME. IN 2018 IT CLOSED AND THE APPLICANT WHO IS THE NEW OWNER OF THE PROPERTY ACQUIRED IT IN APRIL OF 2019 AND GOT A GRANDFATHERED ZONING PERMIT FOR

THE NONCONFORMING USE FOR THE GAS STATION. >> THE CONDITION ON THE PERMIT WAS THAT IT HAD TO BE REESTABLISHED WITHIN A YEAR. IN THE MEANTIME, THE CONVENIENCE STORE THAT'S A PART OF THIS PROPERTY AND THE LIQUOR STORE WERE REESTABLISHED.

>> THEY ARE CURRENTLY UP AND RUNNING BUT THE GAS STATION WAS NOT SUCCESSFULLY REESTABLISHED

IN TIME AND THE PERMIT EXPIRED. >> THE APPLICANT IS INTERESTED IN PURSUING THE C FOR COMMUNITY CENTER MIXED USE REZONING IN ORDER TO RE ESTABLISH THE GAS STATION WHICH IS A CONDITIONAL USE UNDERNEATH THAT REZONING AND THE REASONS BEHIND WHY HE WAS UNABLE TO GET IT DONE THAT WERE GIVEN TO US IS THAT THERE WERE ISSUES WITH GETTING PARTS AND ISSUES WITH THE PANDEMIC.

>> SO THAT'S WHAT HE REPORTED AS THE PROBLEM WITH GETTING THAT GAS STATION BACK UP AND RUNNING. NOW IT'S AN INTERESTING PROPERTY BECAUSE 25 PERCENT

OF THE TWO ACRES OR A HALF AN ACRE IS IN THE ACRES. >> AND AS YOU HEARD MS. KRIEGER SPEAK TO EARLIER, THE COMMUNITY CENTER MIXED USE THE C4 DESIGNATION.

THEY ARE OPPOSED TO THAT REZONING. IT IS THE APC TOO WHICH HAS MEASURABLE RISK FOR ACCIDENTS TO HAPPEN AND THE GAS STATION IS ACTUALLY IN THE PORTION OF THE PROPERTY THAT'S UNDERNEATH THE ACRES APC ZONING.

>> IT'S ALSO THE LOUDEST NOISE CONTOUR. AS WAS MENTIONED DURING PUBLIC COMMENT, IT DOES ALIGN WITH FUTURE LAND USES AND OUR 2010 AND OUR DRAFT 2014

COMPREHENSIVE PLAN. >> BUT IT WOULD BE A SPOT ZONING IF IT CHANGED AND AGAIN

THE AIR STATION IS OPPOSED TO THAT AT THE COMMUNITY. >> COMMERCIAL USES ARE

INCOMPATIBLE WITH ACRES ZONING. >> WE WANT OH SURE. >> SO I WILL LET YOU KNOW JUST

IN MY MIND. >> SO IT DID GO. >> WE DID HAVE THE AIR STATION REVIEW IT. THEY SUBMITTED A LETTER EXPRESSING THAT THEY DO OPPOSE THE REZONING AND IT WENT BEFORE THE BEAUFORT COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION DURING THEIR OCTOBER MEETING WHERE IT WAS A MOTION WAS MADE TO APPROVE THE PROPOSED ZONING AMENDMENT.

>> IT PASSED THREE TO TWO. THEN IT WENT TO THE METROPOLITAN PLANNING COMMISSION WHERE A MOTION WAS MADE TO APPROVE THE ZONING AMENDMENT.

>> IT FAILED TWO TO THREE. >> SO THAT'S WHERE THAT CURRENTLY STANDS AND WE DID

SEND OUR TEAM OUT TO GET DRONE FOOTAGE OF IT. >> BUT IS A HELPFUL ADDITION TO HAVING THESE CONSIDERATIONS BUT BECAUSE IT'S SO CLOSE TO THE AIR STATION IT IS A NO FLY ZONE. SO I'VE GOT AERIAL IMAGERY AND PHOTOS FROM GOOGLE MAPS WHICH

WE WILL START TO GO THROUGH. >> WE'LL GO AHEAD AND GO THROUGH THE SLIDES HERE.

SO THIS JUST GIVES YOU CONTEXT OF THE AREA THE ARROW IS POINTING AT THAT YELLOW PARCEL SO SHOWING THAT IT WOULD BE A SPOT ZONING COMPLETELY SURROUNDED BY THE T TO RURAL NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTIES. CAN ALSO SEE ITS PROXIMITY TO THE AIR STATION AND THEN WE'LL

SCOOT TO THE NEXT. >> HERE IS AN AERIAL IMAGE A LITTLE BIT CLOSER SO YOU CAN SEE HOW THE CURRENT BUILDING ON SITE ADDRESSES TRASK PARKWAY AND THE OVERALL LAYOUT AND SIZE

OF THE PLOT SUCH RIGHT THERE IN THE FRONT. >> WHEREAS THAT APC ZONING IS SKEWED TO THE NEXT AND THEN THESE ARE JUST IMAGES FROM GOOGLE EARTH TO SHOW YOU WHAT

IT LOOKS LIKE COMING DOWN TRACKS PARKWAY. >> SO THIS IS ON YOUR WAY INTO BEAUFORT. YOU CAN SEE THE GAS SECTION ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE STREET.

>> AND THEN WE'LL GO THROUGH OUR LAST SLIDE WHICH SHOWS YOU THE FACE OF THE BUILDING.

>> THIS IS AS GOOD AS IT GETS WITHOUT OUR DRONE FOOTAGE. >> THAT'S VERY HELPFUL.

>> THOSE GOOD GOOD PICTURES. SO IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS. >> ALL RIGHT.

WE'LL OPEN IT UP FOR QUESTIONS. ANYONE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS? I HAD ONE QUESTION.

[00:20:02]

EMBARRASSMENT AS A QUESTION? YES. >> WHERE'S THE NEAREST GAS

STATION THAT IS BEING USED? THERE IS A GAS STATION. >> SO IF WE CAN GO BACK TO THE

POWERPOINT PRESENTATION, I CAN ACTUALLY POINT IT OUT FOR YOU. >> BUT THERE IS A GAS STATION TO THE SOUTH MEASURE MOVING DOWN TRASK PARKWAY AT THE CLARENDON BRUCE CASE SMALLS

TRUST PARKWAY INTERSECTION. >> THERE IS A GAS STATION RIGHT THERE THAT'S IN OPERATION JUST ACROSS FROM THE TRAILHEAD OF THE SPANISH MOSS TRAIL. OK.

AND THEN IF I'M WRONG IN THE DISTANCE I WOULDN'T TEND TO MOVE A THOUSAND FEET.

>> THERE WE GO. AND THAT ONE WAS IS GRANDFATHER BECAUSE IT WAS AN EXISTENCE FOR YES. A CRUISE AND A PIECE. YES.

YES. ADOPTED THE MAN'S QUEST. >> YOU GOT YOU AND MRS. MRS. PARSLEY, YOU FINISH. YEAH. NO.

YOU'VE ANSWERED MY QUESTION. THERE'S A GAS STATION I KNOW USED TO BE A GAS STATION ACROSS THE ROAD FROM THE SHELL STATION THAT YOU IS THERE. WOULD THEY BE PERMITTED TO TO DO ANYTHING WITH A GAS STATION THERE IF THE OWNER PURCHASED IT AND CAME BACK TO DO SOMETHING BECAUSE THAT'S THAT'S THE SAME NICHOLS WOULD. YES, SIR.

THAT THAT INTERSECTION IS SOUND. >> SEE FOR COMMUNITY CENTER MIXED USE WHICH IS WHAT THE APPLICANT IS GOING AFTER RIGHT NOW.

SO IT IS A CONDITIONAL USE UNDER THE CURRENT ZONING BUT THAT WOULD STILL LIKELY NEED REVIEW BY THE AIR STATION JUST BECAUSE I IMAGINE IT'S ALSO IN THE ACRES IN THE APC SOUNDS SO

IT KIND OF DEPENDS ON WHAT IT IS THEY'RE PROPOSING. >> THERE WOULD BE SOME CONDITIONS UNDER THE ACRES AND THEN SOME CONDITIONAL CONDITIONS WITH REGARD TO THE

ZONING ITSELF BECAUSE DOES THAT ANSWER YOUR QUESTION? >> OK.

I MEAN DOES IT TO ME THAT THAT WHOLE AREA LOOKED LIKE A COMMERCIAL ZONE BUT YOU EXPLAIN THAT THAT PARTICULAR CORNER IS LOAN COMMERCIAL AND THEN WITH THIS CURRENT STATION USED TO BE IT WAS ACTUALLY T TO ZORAN ONLY BRANSON. YES, SIR.

THANK YOU. >> WELCOME. SO THE CONVENIENCE STORE AND THE LIQUOR STORE CAN REMAIN OPEN. AS BEING GRANDFATHER THEY HAVE

THEIR GRANDFATHER. >> AND IN 20 I WROTE DOWN 20 19.

>> IT WAS IT WAS CLOSED IN 2018 AND THEN THE NEW OWNERS CAME IN AND TWENTY NINE TO AND I HAD A

YEAR TO GET TO GET THE GAS STATION PART BACKUP. >> YES, MA'AM.

YES. THE PERMIT THE GRANDFATHERED PERMIT WAS ISSUED IN MAY OF TWENTY NINETEEN SO THEY HAD A YEAR TO GET THE GAS STATION BACK UP AND RUNNING.

SO THAT PERMIT EXPIRED AND MAY 20 20 AND IT WAS NOT OPERATIONAL AT THAT TIME BUT THEY OPEN THE LIQUOR STORE CONVENIENCE SIDE OF AND WITHIN THAT YEAR.

>> YES. AND THEY WERE THERE WERE SEPARATE PERMITS FOR EACH

OF THOSE THREE DIFFERENT INDEPENDENT BUSINESSES. >> MADAM CHAIRMAN.

YES. COUNCILMAN DAWSON. YEAH.

>> THIS IS PROPERTY AND BUSINESSES IN MY DISTRICT. YES, MA'AM.

THIS CONVENIENCE STORE, LIQUOR STORE, GAS STATION BY THE PRIOR LAW AS HAVE BEEN IN OPERATION FOR DECADES. THIS IS IN THE MIDDLE OF GRACE. NO COMMUNITY WHICH ACCOMPANIES THE SHERIFF'S STATION WHICH IS JUST UP THE STREET MAYBE TWO TWO AND A HALF FOOTBALL FIELD NOW. MR. GLOVER REFERENCE AN OLD GAS STATION THAT IS CURRENTLY BEING RENOVATED AND MAY COME BACK ON LINE AS WELL. I KNOW THAT THIS BUSINESS OWNER LOST THE OPPORTUNITY TO GET THE BUSINESS LICENSE FOR THE GAS STATION BUT IT BUT I WILL TELL YOU THIS THIS IS A COMMERCIAL HUB AND IT HAS BEEN VIABLE. AND THAT COMMUNITY INTEGRATION COMMUNITY AS I SAY FOR DECADES NOW AND TO GO TO FOR THIS GENTLEMAN TO TRY AND RESURRECT THIS BUSINESS. I THINK IT'S AN ASSET AND SOMETHING THAT THE COMMUNITY WELCOMES THE FACT THAT HIS PERMIT FOR THE GAS STATION HAS EXPIRED.

I BELIEVE WE SHOULD TAKE THE OPPORTUNITY TO AFFORD THIS GENTLEMAN THE OPPORTUNITY TO BRING A GAS STATION BACK ON LINE. HAVING SAID THAT, I I WILL TELL YOU I KNOW THAT AIR STATION AS OPPOSED TO THIS. BUT BY THE SAME TOKEN I I FEEL

[00:25:01]

SO WITH THAT IN MIND I WOULD MAKE A MOTION THAT WE MOVE FORWARD AND ALLOW THE THE GRANT THE PROPERTY LAW THE PERMISSION TO APPLY FOR PERMIT NEEDED TO TO OPEN A GAS STATION AND TAKE THAT IN THE FORM OF A THAT IS A MOTION TO HAVE SECOND TO THE MOTION.

>> QUESTION OH LOOK, WE NEED A SECOND AND WE'LL DISCUSS. >> OK.

WE HAVE A SECOND TO THAT SECOND. OK.

COUNCILMAN GLOVER MADE THE SECOND OK. WE'LL OPEN IT UP FOR DISCUSSION. I THINK THAT WAS COUNCILMAN HIRSCHHORN.

IS THAT CORRECT? YES. THANK YOU.

>> JUST SO I'M CLEAR, THIS PROPERTY REVERT BACK TO RURAL WHEN THE BUSINESS LICENSE LAPSED. WAS THAT HOW WE GOT INTO THIS SITUATION?

>> THIS PROPERTY WAS ZONED TO OUR OWN NEIGHBORHOOD WHEN WE ADOPTED THE THE CDC AND IN FACT IT'S BEEN NON CONFORMING SINCE THE ADOPTION OF THIS EDF SO IN NINETEEN NINETY NINE.

SO IT'S BEEN A NONCONFORMING USE FOR QUITE SOME TIME. >> SO THERE WAS NO CONVERSION NECESSARILY OF THE ZONING THAT IS ON THE PROPERTY. IT'S JUST THAT THE

GRANDFATHERED USE EXPIRED WHEN THE PERMIT EXPIRED. >> GOT IT.

I GOT IT. SO IT'S BEEN AN EXISTING OPERATING BUSINESS AS IT EXISTS TODAY. THIS IS SIMILAR TO ANOTHER PROPERTY THAT WE TALKED ABOUT MAYBE A MONTH OR TWO AGO IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN WHERE I WAS OPERATING AS IT WAS AND WAS NONCONFORMING AND WE BASICALLY CHANGED AS I SAID IT WAS. IF I'M REMEMBERING CORRECTLY ANYWAY BUT I DIGRESS. THAT WAS HELPFUL. THANK YOU.

YOU'RE WELCOME. >> ANY OTHER DISCUSSION QUESTIONS?

>> YES. I JUST PROBABLY I I I KNOW THIS PROPERTY VERY WELL.

>> I KNEW THE FAMILY THAT OWNED IT. GOSH, 60 YEARS AGO 50 YEARS AGO ONE OF THE GIRLS IN MY CLASS PARENTS OWNED IT. BUT THE WHOLE IDEA OF THE GRANDFATHERING IS OBVIOUSLY TO PROTECT SOMEBODY WHO'S ALREADY THERE.

AND WHEN I DON'T THINK ANYBODY WOULD DEBATE THAT. BUT HERE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SOMEBODY WHO LET IT EXPIRE THAT GRANDFATHERING EXPIRE AND NOW WANTS TO GO BACK IN.

ESSENTIALLY THIS IS A START UP . I KNOW THE HISTORY OF THE PROPERTY BUT I'M RELUCTANT TO VOTE FOR ANYBODY TO PUT A SEE FOR IN THIS IN THIS IN THE ACRES FROM SCRATCH. AND TOM, I HAVE TO VOTE AGAINST IT BECAUSE I THINK WE'RE JUST OPENING UP PANDORA'S BOX IF WE'RE GONNA GIVE THIS GENTLEMAN A SEAT.

WHAT ABOUT THE NEXT GENTLEMAN OR LADY OR PERSON COMES IN AND SAYS HEY, WE WANT TO PUT SOMETHING IN THIS. I WANT TO BE CONSISTENT. AND SO I'M GOING TO HAVE TO

VOTE. I'M HAVE TO VOTE NO IN THIS. >> ANY OTHER COMMENTS?

>> YES. WITH MR. SOMERVILLE IS WELL. HOWEVER CAN CAN THIS OWNER GRAPH CONTINUE TO BE GRANDFATHERED IN OR GIVE UP ANY TO GRANDFATHER HIS PROPERTY AND WITH THE THE METHOD FAILED TO MEET? WE JUST EXTEND THAT TO ALLOW HIM WITHOUT CHANGING THE ZONING ON IT OR WE HAVE TO CHANGE THE ZONING IN ORDER FOR HIM TO DO WHAT HE WANTS TO DO TO GET CLOSURE. YES, SIR.

SO I THINK THAT THE DEADLINE WAS THERE. BUT I HEAR WHAT MR. DAWSON IS SAYING AND YEAH, THAT IS SOMETHING IF YOU ARE ON PLAN I WOULD LIKE TO TAKE SOME TIME TO INVEST, GET COUPLE OF THINGS ARE AT PLAY HERE THAT YOU ALL NEED TO BE AWARE STOOD UP AND TAUGHT YOU ALL ABOUT FOUR OF THE WITH REGARDS TO ZONING PROPERTIES AND GRANDFATHERING IN THE WHOLE OF THE RECALL RECENTLY OVER THE LAST SIX MONTHS.

[00:30:07]

>> YOU ALL HAVE DREAMS ON GRANDFATHERED PROPERTIES BECAUSE THEY WERE JUST THAT GRANDFATHERED RIGHT. HEY, YOU KNOW THIS IS JUST THE BUSINESS THEY WEREN'T WEARING ZONING. THEY DIDN'T KNOW IT WAS ON THEIR TAX BILL.

WE'RE GOING TO REZONE THEIR PROPERTIES IN OPPOSITION TO STASH RECOMMENDATION AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION. SO THAT'S ONE ISSUE. THE SECOND ISSUE AND THIS IS WHAT I NEED TO INVESTIGATE LEGALLY IS THE ZONING CONSTRUCTION TYPICALLY WHENEVER YOU'RE DEALING WITH A GRANDFATHERED SITUATION, IF A BUILDING SO SITUATED TO APPROVE ONE COMMERCIAL USE THEN THAT USE MAY CONTINUE THROUGHOUT THAT BUILDING.

SO IF THE PUMPS ARE STILL THEY ARE THEY CANNOT BE STILL THERE. EVERYTHING IS STILL THERE.

THEN THERE MIGHT BE A POSSIBILITY TO YOUR FORM THAT WE COULD GRANDFATHER THE PROPERTY AND I'M GOING TO TAKE ONE OTHER LIBERTY AND I PROBABLY SHOULD NOT DO THIS IF I MISTAKE THIS FOR OVERSTEP MY BALANCE. PLEASE FORGIVE ME BUT I TOO COUNTS MOVE AND ALSO SHARE HIS CONCERNS ABOUT THE CONSISTENCY OF THE AIR STATION WITH THE ENFORCEMENT A CUZ THEY'RE TAKING A POSITION ON THIS TO SAY HEY WE CAN'T ALLOW THESE FOLKS TO HAVE GAS PUMPS BUT RIGHT DOWN THE ROAD ACTUALLY THEY DID NOT A FEW YEARS AGO A DOLLAR GENERAL THAT SOME OF Y'ALL GOT CALLS ON THEY HAVE NOW ALLOWED ARE IN THE PROCESS OF ALLOWING SOMEONE TO PUT A MOBILE HOME DEALERSHIP ON THE PROPERTY THAT'S GOING TO GENERATE FAR MORE PEOPLE ON THAT PROPERTY WALKING AROUND OUTSIDE LOOKING AT MOBILE HOMES THAN THEY WOULD BEFORE. IN ADDITION TO THAT ON THE OTHER PROPERTY THAT MR. RIBAUT JUST REFERRED TO THAT WE'RE PAYING YOU KNOW, THEY'RE CONCERNED ABOUT THE AIR SPACE.

YEAH, WE ARE PROVEN WE APPROVE ON A CONSERVATION EASEMENT WITH A FORTY FIVE ACRE DUCK ON ON THE PROPERTY AND BARGE STRIKES ONE OF THE KEY MISS MISS ITEMS WITHIN WITH ONE OF THE KEY THINGS THAT YOU DO NOT ALLOW IN THE EGG USES GENERATES A LOT OF CONCERN.

SO IF YOU ALL WOULD APPROVE THIS EVELYN AND FORWARD AND ON THE COUNCIL TAMMY GOES TO COUNCIL YOU'D RECOMMEND IT SOMEHOW THIS EVENING OR FOR APPROVAL OR DENIAL.

WE'LL HAVE AN ANSWER FOR YOUR PARTY COUNCIL MEETING AND GIVE YOU SOME CLEAR LEGAL DIRECTION ON WHAT WE DO HERE. YES, MR. CRANE, MY DEAR POINT REGARDING APPROVING IT TONIGHT

I WOULD RATHER TABLE PERSONALLY AS CHAIRMAN. >> I DON'T KNOW IF I HAVE THE RIGHT TO DO THAT BUT I WOULD RATHER TABLE AND BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE.

I THINK YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK FOR THE COMMUNITY TO DEFER ACTION ON THIS.

AND IF YOU CAN GET THAT DEFERRED ACTION, I TAKE YOU BACK TO YOU IN NOVEMBER AND DECEMBER. I'M SORRY. OKAY.

SO COUNCILMAN DOSS, I THINK THERE'S A LOT OF QUESTIONS. I HOPE YOU DON'T.

I HOPE YOU WILL AGREE. I THINK WE SHOULD DEFER THIS AND GET AN ANSWER AT THE

COMMITTEE LEVEL BEFORE WE FORWARD IT. >> DO I NEED YOUR HELP? THIS IS KIND OF A LEGAL QUESTION. IF I CAN DO THAT AS CHAIRMAN, I

WILL. MR. CRANE. >> MADAM CHAIRMAN, I'LL I'LL

MAKE IT EASIER FOR YOU. I'LL WITHDRAW THE MOTION. >> OKAY, GREAT.

THAT DOES. AND WE WILL WAIT AND DEFER IT UNTIL WE CAN GET SOME MORE LEGAL ADVICE ON IT. MY OTHER QUESTION IS HAVE YOU NEED TO TAKE THE SECOND TERM?

YES. >> OKAY COUNCILMAN GO AND DEFERRED TO THE DECEMBER.

I HAVE NO PROBLEM. I WAS SUPPORTING MR. DAWSON. OKAY.

BUT I WAS ALSO LEANING TO PAUL. >> SO I HAVE A QUESTION REGARDING FOR THE LEGAL SIDE OF IT. THOSE TANKS HAVE PROBABLY BEEN REMOVED IF THEY WERE LEAKING.

I DON'T THINK SO. YOU DON'T THINK TANKS HAVE BEEN REMOVED? THAT'S A QUESTION I HAVE AS A CANOPY. THE PUMPS MIGHT BE THERE BUT I DON'T KNOW. THE TANKS HAVE BEEN REMOVED OR NOT.

SOME PLACES YOU SAY THAT YOU THINK IS REMOVE WAS DELAYED OR NOW I'D JUST LIKE TO KNOW IS STILL THERE. I MEAN I MEAN IT'S NOT LOOKING TO GET BACK TO YOU BUT IN CONVERSATIONS WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER I WAS WORKING TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY WERE STILL IN REGULAR. OKAY. ALL RIGHT.

THAT'S ANOTHER GOOD. ANOTHER THING WE NEED TO FIND. OKAY.

COUNCILMAN PAST WHEN HAD HIS HAND UP CHAIRMAN OF ONE OF THE THINGS THAT ERIC RAISED IS THE GAS STATION IS PLACED THERE. IT WAS A GAS STATION. IT WAS TO RURAL BUT THIS WAS A NONCONFORMING PROPERTY WHICH MEANS THAT THE OTHER TWO BUSINESSES WERE ALSO NON CONFORMING BUT THEY IN FACT ARE NOW UP AND RUNNING. SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE'RE

[00:35:02]

ALSO LIFE ALSO PROVIDES FOR THE CELL GASOLINE. SO THAT'S WHAT I NEED TO WORK WITH OUR LEGAL DEPARTMENT. AND DO SOME RESEARCH ON MAKE SURE WE UNDERSTAND WHAT THE

WHAT THE LIMITATIONS ARE. OK, THAT HELPS ME. >> IT'S JUST YES.

ALEX HAS HIS HAND UP YET THERE'S AN INDIVIDUAL ON AN INDIVIDUAL ONLINE.

ALEX? >> YES. THIS IS THE ACTUAL OWNER OF THE GAS STATION. MY NAME IS ALEX, THE MAN I REPRESENT LOWCOUNTRY LEGACY.

I HAVE A CONCERN ABOUT STORAGE TANKS. OK.

WE WE DID ACTUALLY PHASE TWO ENVIRONMENTAL STUDY BEFORE THE GAS STATION WAS PURCHASED AND

THERE IS CURRENTLY NO LEAKS. >> OK, THANK YOU. >> ALSO THE HACK.

I CURRENTLY HOLD THE CERTIFICATE. TYPING THIS TEST WAS DONE AND THERE IS TANKS IN THE APPROPRIATE TANKS AN OLD PIPE IN THE OPERATING CONDITION.

ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU FOR CLARIFICATION ON THAT.

OK. ANY OTHER ANYTHING ELSE ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO ASK QUESTIONS ABOUT? OK, WE'RE GOING TO DEFER THIS TO THE NEXT MEETING.

[11. APPOINTMENT OF GAIL MURRAY TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A PARTIAL 1st TERM WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE OF 2024 ]

APPOINTMENT? >> SO MOVE MADAM. THANK YOU.

COUNCILMAN DAWSON, I HAVE A SECOND. >> SECOND.

ALL RIGHT. SECOND BY COUNCILMAN GLOVER. ANY DISCUSSION?

[12. CONSIDERATION OF APPOINTMENT FOR JANE FREDERICK TO ZONING BOARD FOR A PARTTIAL 1st TERM WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE OF 2024 ]

I HAVE A MOTION. I'LL MAKE THAT MOTION. SHE'S IN MY DISTRICT.

OKAY. THANK YOU, COUNCILMAN SOMERVILLE.

WE HAVE A MOTION. DO WE HAVE A SECOND? COUNCILMAN GLOVER, WAIT A SECOND. ALL RIGHT. WITHOUT EXCEPTION, THE APPOINTMENT OF JANE FREDERICK TO THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS WILL MOVE TO FULL COUNCIL

MEMBER 2 YES. >> IF YOU SEE FILLING A POSITION AS THE PROFESSIONAL PERSON WAS THE MISS MISS BROUGHT FROM HIS BOND CAN YOU ANSWER THAT BECAUSE SHE IS AN

ARCHITECT AND MORE THAN NO PLAN B FOR COUNTY. >> BUT AFTER LOOKING SO IT'S JUST A REGULAR POSITION THAT'S OK. AND THAT ANSWERS A QUESTION

[13. CONSIDERATION OF APPOINTMENT FOR WILLIAM BEDINGFIELD TO SOUTHERN BEAUFORT COUNTY CORRIDOR BEAUTIFICATION BOARD FOR A 1ST TERM WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE OF 2024 ]

RIBAUT COUNCILMAN GLOVER. >> DO I HAVE A SECOND TO THAT MOTION?

>> I'LL BE HAPPY TO DO IT. >> OBVIOUSLY SOMEBODY HIMSELF ABROAD IS SOMEONE WHO'S OUTSIDE

THE BROAD LIGHT TO MAKE THAT MOTION HAPPY TO DO THAT. >> OK, THAT WAS COUNCILMAN MIKE

ALLEN. >> YES. THANK YOU.

RIBAUT. ALL RIGHT. WITHOUT EXCEPTION, MR. REDDING FEELS NOMINATION WILL GO FORWARD TO THE FULL COUNCIL. IS THERE ANY OTHER BUSINESS IN FRONT OF IN FRONT OF THE NATURAL RESOURCE COMMITTEE? NOT.

WE STAND ADJOURNED. THANK YOU. >>

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.